PlateSurf
Brooklyn · Prospect Heights

GERTIE

A Brooklyn deli that brings authentic New York bagel culture to Prospect Heights

AmericanLunch spot
GERTIE

What to know

GERTIE opened to revive the ritual of the neighborhood bagel run while honoring classic deli craft. Founded by local operators who studied traditional techniques, the shop focuses on kettle boiling, careful proofing, and bold house-made spreads. It matters because it re-centers everyday food culture — the simple pleasure of a perfectly textured bagel and a properly stacked sandwich — in a changing Brooklyn neighborhood. The result is both comforting and distinctly of its borough.