About Pie Boy Pizza
Pie Boy Pizza is a pop-up residency inside Baby’s Bagels that reimagines the neighborhood pizza shop with a Utah sensibility. The menu keeps it simple and focused—paper plates of hot, thin-crust pies, a bright Caesar, and a small selection of beer, wine, and cocktails—served counter-style with first-come, first-served seating. Pre-order online for takeaway or linger at the counter for a casual, city-center bite.
What to Order
Margherita (New York–style)
A classic thin-crust pie with blistered mozzarella, tangy San Marzano-style tomato, fresh basil, and a kiss of olive oil.
Pepperoni Pie
Paper-plate perfection: lots of crisp-edged pepperoni atop a chewy, foldable crust and bright tomato sauce.
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine, garlicky dressing, shaved Parmesan, and house croutons—clean, crunchy, and ideal alongside any slice.